Six Nations shows World Cup is wide open - Kayes

Henry Slade 1566174663

In their first match of the Six Nations they failed, folding spectacularly under the weight of expectation, thumped 32-20 by England with the final score flattering Ireland.


The Irish media called it a humiliating defeat and veteran match commentator Michael Corcoran told me it was a bafflingly poor performance.

He thinks the Six Nations is now a competition between England and Wales and that it could be decided when they meet in Cardiff in round three.

On the flip side, England are on the rise and will be increasing talked up as World Cup contenders - with the requisite suggestion that the gap to the All Blacks has disappeared.

The reality is very little has changed with the first round of the Six Nations.

It’s not a surprise England won. They are a decent team. The manner and margin is the only surprise especially as Ireland dominated many of the game stats expect the only one that really matters, the score.
They had more ball than England - 52 percent in the first half and 67 per cent in the second; their four penalties were half England’s and they missed only 13 tackles to England’s 28.

It shows yet again that in the modern era it’s not how much ball you have but what you do with it.

It’s not really a surprise Ireland struggled with the weight of expectation. Being fancied is unfamiliar. Ireland are at their best when they’re dismissed, written off, cast as the underdog.

It’s equally not a surprise that France were superb for 40 minutes then dreadful in the second half, or that Wales somehow conjured a win from a poor performance.

They’ve won 10 tests on the trot and as their Kiwi coach Warren Gatland quipped after the game, Wales don’t know how to lose and France have forgotten how to win.

Equally unsurpising was Scotland’s win against Italy who have been making up the numbers since they increased the Five Nations to six.

Scotland are a good team but there might be concern about how they let in three tries in the final nine minutes. What does that say about their fitness? Or did they simply ease off because the game was won?

In Dublin, England were superb, with the pack, anchored by the almost tireless prop Mako Vunipola, laying the platform for Owen Farrell to drive his side around the park.

Outside him Manu Tuilagi and Henry Slade combined nicely in the midfield, Tuilagi again showing the benefits of having a powerful, straight running second five.

Rugby has changed over the years but what remains indisputable is that it’s an easy game to play with front foot ball. Tuilagi and England’s pack provided that.


So does the first round mean Ireland’s bubble has burst? Not really. They were always a chance to lose in the Six Nations. It’s how they respond to this defeat against Scotland next week that will provide a better World Cup pointer.

Can they adapt to being expected to win every week - a pressure the All Blacks live with week in and out.

Are England suddenly World Cup favourites? No more than they already were. They are a serious contender.

The opening round of Six Nations rugby confirmed for me that this year’s World Cup in Japan is the most wide open in the tournament’s history.

Any of New Zealand, South Africa, Ireland, Wales and England are quite capable of winning it; while France and Australia are outside chances.
And before you remind me that the Wallabies are a shambles, just remember, that was the case four years ago too - and they lost in the final!

Scotland and Argentina probably won’t be able to string enough top drawer performances together to win the Cup, but they will upset at least one of the more fancied teams.

As for the Six Nations, it’s still a four-team competition at least but Ireland are no longer the hot favourites they were.

Henry Slade 1566174663




Jim Kayes

Jim Kayes has been covering rugby since the late 1990s across print/online, radio and television with The Dominion Post,, TV3 and Newshub, Radio Live and Radio Sport. He's been to five World Cups, covered almost 200 All Blacks Tests and was on safari with the Lions when the British and Irish side last toured New Zealand, in 2005.